When I check the keyword searches that land people here, a lot of
them have to do with "find my strengths" or "how do I manage talented
people?"
People at work appear invested in clarifying their own strengths and understanding the inherent talent in others. If that's so, I was wondering why there is so much angst about retention. It seems that people would be committed for the long term if their strengths and talents are being valued.
The Managerial Equivalent of "Your Lips Say 'Yes' But There's 'No-No' In Your Eyes"
There is at least one reason why some people--including managers-- are shopping their resumes. It has to do with the distinction between advocating development and then doing the opposite.
Here's a real life example:
Luke (not his real name) is an operations manager at one of my client companies. He's experienced and has been in the manufacturing industry for 20+ years. He is the most well-read client ever. Whenever I see him, he waxes poetically about the wonderful "new" managerial ideas he's picked up from the most recent leadership books he's read.
One of those ideas had to do with recognizing someone's small successes and following through with verbal encouragement or even a small reward (lunch, movie tickets, a $25 gift certificate. . .) Better yet, acknowledge the person's fete during a regular departmental meeting. He also talked about the importance of those ideas during a meeting with his supervisors.
But he wouldn't do any of those.
I asked him why not.
His reply "I'm not going to spend time rewarding or telling someone how good they are if the company is already paying them a salary. They are supposed to do good work."
He doesn't have the same approach with his kids. I've seen him. He acknowledges them when they've succeeded at something. Anything. And he does it spontaneously.
What the heck happens in life(?) between:
and
Every day we're all trying to learn or do something new. Let's be honest: part of our day is spent being a kid again when it comes to struggling with a new problem that needs a solution. And we could use a few encouraging words of recognition when we demonstrate a talent that helps the organization.
("Gee, that felt good. I think I'll do it again!)
What would a well-known, successful business person say about the importance of encouragement?
Photo attribution to:
www.mingara.com.au
www.corporateclowning.nl















I find it disheartening that your friend "Luke" knows a best practice for encouraging his employees but doesn't want to do it. Did you make any progress with him on it?
My husband Eric has worked for a government agency for 7 years. During that time, he has told me about some recognition programs that seem to be highly motivational for him and his co-workers: day off rewards, cash awards, and personal letters of commendation/medals. What has seemed more significant to him, though, is verbal recognition of a job well done.
Posted by: Becky Robinson | June 22, 2009 at 07:11 AM
Hi Steve,
Employees are aching for recognition. In these tough times, this is more important than ever.
And many employees prefer recognition that is "customized" to them. Every person is different, and if managers would ask how they would like to be thanked (within boundaries, of course; a manager might want to take any form of compensation off the table), they might find that some (the extraverts) love public recognition and others (introverts) prefer that it be provided in private conversation or in writing (in fact, introverts might indicate that public recognition is embarassing for them).
However, recognition, "thank you", and especially heartfelt gratitude (largely for the reason you cite) is so absent from our workplaces that most employees would appreciate it any way they can get it!
Posted by: Mary Jo Asmus | June 22, 2009 at 08:51 AM
Becky,
No, I made no progress. The reason was quite simple: Luke was seen by his boss as a terrific technical "manager" (true) who "couldn't be replaced" (false). So, Luke never had to really worry about the consequences of his lack of recognizing people: he got the message that "This is something you should do but we won't zap you if you don't".
Posted by: Steve Roesler | June 22, 2009 at 08:57 AM
Mary Jo,
After so many years of involvement with this, you'd think we'd just give up at some point, eh?
But the fact is, "thank you" costs nothing but a moment in time and the benefits can last for days or even months. It still baffles me how a common social courtesy somehow manages to disappear inside the Cavern of Corporate Cubicles.
Posted by: Steve Roesler | June 22, 2009 at 09:01 AM
Hi Steve,
In my experience many of the Lukes and Lucies of the work world never experienced a deep degree of acknowledgement and recognition when they were growing up. So, they never learned how to "return the favor" and this imprint on their brain and in their psyche plays out in their adult life. Yes, they read all the management stuff, but it doesn't compute – it's just words. No different than reading all the nice stuff about self-help but really "do-ing" nothing about it.
In another vein, those who are competitive and live from a "zero-sum" game actually believe, albeit unconsciously, that "if you get yours, then I won't get mine." It's actually "hard" for these folks to give a compliment because they don't feel they "get theirs" often enough.
His reply, "I'm not going to spend time rewarding or telling someone how good they are if the company is already paying them a salary. They are supposed to do good work," for me is a red herring. That's his "public voice." His "private voice" actually reflects what I mentioned above.
In the context of his home life, he may be more emotionally mature, more adult, thus his response to his children. On another note, how is he in this regard with his spouse in the giving (and wanting) compliments and recognition?
In the workplace, he may still largely be the emotionally immature child. Many leaders and managers are.
Posted by: peter vajda | June 22, 2009 at 09:45 AM
Peter,
Your final question gave me pause. As I thought about what I have observed, he is much more engaged with the (now adult) children when it comes to compliments and recognition that with his wife.
Something to ponder. . .
Posted by: Steve Roesler | June 22, 2009 at 10:24 AM
Isn't it amazing that people refuse to consider such a thing, presuming that a paycheck is enough "thanks" for a job well done? Para-paycheck recognition is the difference for many folks between doing their job and doing it well. After a graphic designer in our marketing dept kicked butt on short deadlines for my team twice in a row, I gave her a $50 Ticketmaster gift card out of my own pocket because I wanted her to know how much I appreciated her work. I think the rest of the higher-ups at my office have forgotten that nine- and ten-hour days, six days a week, for months on end aren't actually normal, nor are they healthy for people. A simple gesture of thanks can boost someone's spirits and keep them performing well...and keep them at your firm doing good work. By the way, when I ask for help with something or have edits on a presentation with that graphic designer, she's very helpful and goes above and beyond to help me.
Posted by: Mile High Pixie | June 28, 2009 at 04:24 PM
Nice post Steve! I don't think most managers realize how far simple acknowledgement and recognition can really go with engaging and retaining employees. Thanks for sharing this!
I've featured you post in my weekly Rainmaker 'Fab Five' blog picks of the week (found here: http://www.maximizepossibility.com/employee_retention/2009/06/the-rainmaker-fab-five-blog-picks-of-the-week-4.html) to share your message with my readers.
Have a great week Steve!
- Chris
Posted by: Chris Young | June 29, 2009 at 12:52 AM