The real world is weighing in on HR.
It's one thing to exchange thoughtful comments about Systemic HR; it's another to be a customer.
I received the email below from an employee at a large East Coast institution. An exchange revealed the juxtaposition of the terms "HR" and "Success" sent up a flag. The writer graduated from a major university with a high GPA, scholastic honors, leadership experiences, and is multi-lingual:
"Your opening paragraph caught my attention:
HR folks may be the only ones in an organization who knew you before you got the job; participated in getting you into the job; helped orient you to your job; participated in your development for the next job; listens to what you hate about your job; talks to your boss about what you hate about your boss and how (s)he manages your job; and maybe even escorts you out of your job--and the building. (What the heck, Elvis became famous for leaving the building).
Participated in getting you into the job
I had one phone interview by someone who had been on the job for TWO days
Helped orient you to your job
By “orient,” you mean get my photo IDs and have me sign a bunch of papers, then yes…otherwise, that would’ve been the actual people in my dept.
Participated in your development for the next job
This is foreign to me
Listens to what you hate about your job
Also foreign
Talks to your boss about what you hate about your boss and how (s)he manages your job
Foreign
And maybe even escorts you out of your job--and the building
Foreign, fortunately – however, I did see this happen to someone on my floor
Considering how many other interviews I was on (or how many potential interviews I wasn’t even brought in for), I am convinced there is no rhyme or reason in the hiring selection process (perhaps resulting from a lack of ‘process,’ or a faulty one).
Honestly – and this is kind of scary – I’m not really even sure why I was initially hired. Think about that for a minute."
What to make of this?
OK, it isn't a scientific random sampling. But the individual took the time to read the article, respond to it, exchange emails about it, and didn't dump on the company's name nor that of a manager, co-worker, etc. It was clear that the experiences had to do with deep impressions gained from interactions with different HR reps at many different organizations-- including the now-employer.
If we're talking about the systemic nature of organizations, how were the "hiring" organizations ultimately impacted in their "war for talent" efforts? Can a single HR rep almost bring an organization to its knees without anyone ever realizing what's going on at the front end? Does the effort to automate hiring using keyword searches and clunky websites really compensate for a highly qualified human interviewer?
What else is happening at the intersection of people and systems (specifically HR here) that isn't delivering the (hopefully professional) desired results?
_________________________________________________________________________________________
What are some of the real--and really readable--HR pros up to?
- Who cares about those health care premiums when those wild-and-crazy Germans are firing people for, uh, not smoking? Really. Kris Dunn is on the case.
photo attribuion: www.lanl.gov/
Like this article? Subscribe to my RSS feed.
Recent Comments